6 Comments
User's avatar
Khal Spencer, Ph.D.'s avatar

Sounds good. I think the analogy to bike education is somewhat relevant. When I was president of the Hawaii Bicycling League, the statewide bicycle organization in Hawaii, I got familiar with HBL’s long established 4th Grade BikeEd program. We wait till 4th grade because we learned, or perhaps taught ourselves, that you needed to be 9-10 years old before it made any sense to teach kids how to ride safely on public roads. Even quiet public roads.

Expand full comment
David Yamane's avatar

Indeed. I don't know what the lowest age is for allowing kids to swim or use a firearm unsupervised. Interesting to think about 9-10 for riding bikes on public roads unsupervised. That would be just before adolescence (or at it, depending on when the onset of puberty is these days), so that tracks.

Expand full comment
Rich Egan's avatar

I help run a Jr Rifle program at a local club. We often have kid as young as 8 because younger they usually can't really hold the rifle even though we small Marlin model 15s. But we have had 7yo shoot small .22 caliber pistols - single shot. And the look of joy most of the time is amazing. They also listened and paid attention to gun safety, 3-4 I think may be too young as they are too small for even the smallest of handguns.

Expand full comment
David Yamane's avatar

Thanks, Rich. I think with 3-5 year olds it is bench shooting with adult assistance. Your experience is certainly more the norm. But I don't think that 3-5 year olds shooting is a black swan event. It does raise the question of how to address kids' natural curiosity about things that can harm them.

Expand full comment
Winston Smith's avatar

When you mentioned "A Gun is Not a Toy," I immediately thought of Julie Golob's book "Toys, Tools, Guns & Rules".

https://www.amazon.com/Toys-Tools-Guns-Rules-Childrens/dp/0999645609/

It doesn't cover any earth-shattering material, but it is a simple way of initiating "the talk" with kids about guns.

Expand full comment
David Yamane's avatar

Great call. This makes me think also of Rob Pincus' and Yehuda Rehmer's childrens books.

https://amzn.to/3YfmdOq

https://amzn.to/4ccLtdY

Expand full comment